Hamlet, the Catcher in the Rye, and the Age-Old Story of Teen Angst

Despite what marketers would have you believe,both fence.
angst is not just a gelled, chiseled, perfectlyThe major point of divergence comes when
unkempt product of the Twilight phenomenon.Hamlet subliminates his quiet rage through the
Holden Caulfield is king of twentieth-century angst,death of his uncle... not to mention his mom, his
and he was kicking around with a buzz cut back ingirlfriend, his girlfriend's brother, his girlfriend's
the 1950's. Søren Kierkegaard set thefather, his two closest friends, and himself.
philosophical bar for angst in the nineteenthCompare that to The Catcher in the Rye, which
century and managed to do so while wearing aends with Holden apparently having been
top hat. And who can forget Prince Hamlet, thecommitted to a mental institution with all his
skull-carrying, pantaloon-wearing original angst-erfrustrations alive and kicking hard.
of the European canon?If we take into consideration the fact that the
Kierkegaard, of course, looked at angst from aprince of Denmark is just a few rungs below, you
strictly Western, Christian viewpoint, but literaryknow, Most Powerful Guy in the Country - at a
figures like Holden and Hamlet have a much moretime when swordfighting and poisoning are still
universal register. (That is, unless you're tired of allconsidered fairly run-of-the-mill - the apparent
the agonizing and hesitancy, in which case youaudacity of his act diminishes, especially
should go read To Kill a Mockingbird for some ofconsidering it takes all five acts of Hamlet for him
Scout's shoot-first-ask-questions-later wisdom.) Into even work up the nerve to do it. Holden, on
fact, despite the potential language barrier (Hamlet:the other hand, doesn't hesitate to attack his
"what / is this quintessence of dust? Man delightsmacho jerk of a roommate "right smack in the
not me"; Holden: "That guy Morrow was about astoothbrush, so it would split his goddam throat
sensitive as a goddam toilet seat") the two haveopen." Even though the attack fails, this is pretty
a remarkable amount in common.bold for a 17-year old prep school kid living during
Both Hamlet and Holden are privileged, lovesickthe era in US history that coined the term
young men scarred by the death of a family"cooties."
member. As a result of their mute suffering, theyHolden's fighting spirit evaporates over the course
feel - and make a point of becoming - alienatedof the novel, however, and after losing his second
from their respective communities. (Which is nofight, he imagines he's a gangster with a bullet in
big loss, considering that they both think the worldhis belly and his best girl at his side. "The goddam
is full of hypocrites and imposters.) Lashing outmovies," he laments. "They can ruin you." And
through passive aggression, Holden and Hamlet lieperhaps he's right, considering that our modern,
to / generally screw with people until their sanitycivilized notion of catharsis usually involves renting
becomes a matter of debate. And if that isn'tmovies and letting the scenarios wash over you.
enough to convince you of their oddly parallelMaybe Twilight's onto something after all.
lives, just bear in mind the fact that they can